| 2025 | Bradley Cooper, Yannick Nézet-Séguin and Jason Ruder, compilation producers; Steven Gizicki, music supervisor (Maestro: Music by Leonard Bernstein)beat 4 others- Nick Baxter, Blitz Bazawule and Stephen Bray, compilation producers; Jordan Carroll and Morgan Rhodes, music supervisors (The Color Purple)
- Dave Jordan, Shawn Levy and Ryan Reynolds, compilation producers; Dave Jordan, music supervisor (Deadpool & Wolverine)
- Emerald Fennell, compilation producer; Kirsten Lane, music supervisor (Saltburn)
- Ian Cripps, Brandon Davis, Joe Khoury and Kevin Weaver, compilation producers; Mike Knobloch and Rachel Levy, music supervisors (Twisters: The Album)
| Not listed |
| 2024 | Brandon Davis, Mark Ronson and Kevin Weaver, compilation producers; George Drakoulias, music supervisor (Barbie the Album)beat 4 others- Brandon Davis, Pete Ganbarg, Joseph Khoury and Blake Mills, compilation producers; Frankie Pine, music supervisor (Aurora)
- Ryan Coogler, Archie Davis and Ludwig Göransson, compilation producers; Dave Jordan, music supervisor (Black Panther: Wakanda Forever – Music from and Inspired By)
- Kevin Feige, James Gunn and Dave Jordan, compilation producers; Dave Jordan, music supervisor (Guardians of the Galaxy, Vol. 3: Awesome Mix, Vol. 3)
- Leo Birenberg, Zach Robinson and Al Yankovic, compilation producers; Suzanne Coffman, music supervisor (Weird: The Al Yankovic Story)
| Not listed |
| 2023 | Mike Elizondo, Tom MacDougall and Lin-Manuel Miranda, compilation producers; David Boucher and Joey Raia, engineers/mixers (Encanto)beat 4 others- Dave Cobb, Baz Luhrmann, Jameson Shaw and Elliott Wheeler, compilation producers; Anton Monsted, music supervisor (Elvis)
- Matt Duffer and Ross Duffer, compilation producers; Nora Felder, music supervisor (Stranger Things: Soundtrack from the Netflix Original Series, Season 4 (Vol. 2))
- Lorne Balfe, Harold Faltermeyer, Lady Gaga and Hans Zimmer, compilation producers (Top Gun: Maverick)
- David Newman, Matt Sullivan and Jeanine Tesori, compilation producers (West Side Story)
| Not listed |
| 2022 | Salaam Remi, compilation producer; Lynn Fainchtein, music supervisor; Jimmy Douglass, Ryan Evans and Salaam Remi, engineers/mixers (The United States vs. Billie Holiday)beat 6 others- Craig Gillespie, compilation producer; Susan Jacobs, music supervisor (Cruella)
- Alex Lacamoire, Benj Pasek, Justin Paul and Dan Romer, compilation producers; Jordan Carroll, music supervisor (Dear Evan Hansen)
- Alex Lacamoire, Lin-Manuel Miranda, Bill Sherman and Greg Wells, compilation producers; Steven Gizicki, music supervisor (In the Heights)
- Nicholai Baxter, compilation producer; Randall Poster, music supervisor (One Night in Miami...)
- Stephen Bray and Jason Michael Webb, compilation producers (Respect)
- Doug Besterman, Cinco Paul and Scott M. Riesett, compilation producers (Schmigadoon! Episode 1)
| Not listed |
| 2021 | Taika Waititi, compilation producer (Jojo Rabbit)beat 4 others- Nate Heller, compilation producer; Howard Paar, music supervisor (A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood)
- Jonathan Leahy, compilation producer (Bill & Ted Face the Music)
- Savan Kotecha, compilation producer; Becky Bentham, music supervisor (Eurovision Song Contest: The Story of Fire Saga)
- Kristen Anderson-Lopez, Robert Lopez, Tom MacDougall and Dave Metzger, compilation producers (Frozen 2)
| Not listed |
| 2020 | Paul "DJWS" Blair, Bradley Cooper, Lady Gaga, Nick Monson, Lukas Nelson, Mark Nilan Jr. and Benjamin Rice, compilation producers; Julianne Jordan and Julia Michels, music supervisors; Tom Elmhirst, engineer/mixer (A Star Is Born)beat 4 others- Jon Favreau and Hans Zimmer, compilation producers (The Lion King: The Songs)
- Quentin Tarantino, compilation producer; Mary Ramos, music supervisor (Once Upon a Time in Hollywood)
- Giles Martin, compilation producer (Rocketman)
- Spring Aspers and Dana Sano, compilation producers; Kier Lehman, music supervisor (Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse)
| Not listed |
| 2019 | Alex Lacamoire, Benj Pasek, Justin Paul and Greg Wells, compilation producers; Derik Lee, Ian MacGregor and Greg Wells, engineers/mixers (The Greatest Showman)beat 4 others- Luca Guadagnino, compilation producer; Robin Urdang, music supervisor (Call Me by Your Name)
- David Leitch and Ryan Reynolds, compilation producers; John Houlihan, music supervisor (Deadpool 2)
- Timothy J. Smith, compilation producer; Michael Hill and Brian Ross, music supervisors (Lady Bird)
- Matt Duffer, Ross Duffer and Timothy J. Smith, compilation producers; Nora Felder, music supervisor (Stranger Things)
| Not listed |
| 2018 | Justin Hurwitz and Marius de Vries, compilation producers, Steven Gizicki, music supervisor; Nicholai Baxter, engineer/mixer (La La Land)beat 4 others- Edgar Wright, compilation producer (Baby Driver)
- James Gunn, compilation producer (Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2: Awesome Mix Vol. 2)
- Pharrell Williams, compilation producer (Hidden Figures: The Album)
- Opetaia Foa'i, Tom MacDougall, Mark Mancina and Lin-Manuel Miranda, compilation producers (Moana: The Songs)
| Not listed |
| 2017 | Steve Berkowitz, Don Cheadle and Robert Glasper, compilation producers; Ed Gerrard, music supervisor (Miles Ahead)beat 4 others- Salaam Remi and Mark Ronson, compilation producers; Iain Cooke, music supervisor (Amy)
- O'Shea Jackson and Andre Young, compilation producers; Jojo Villanueva, music supervisor (Straight Outta Compton)
- Mike Caren, Darren Higman and Kevin Weaver, compilation producers; Gabe Hilfer and Season Kent, music supervisors (Suicide Squad (Collector's Edition))
- Stewart Lerman, Randall Poster and Kevin Weaver, compilation producers; Meghan Currier, music supervisor (Vinyl: The Essentials Season 1)
| Not listed |
| 2016 | Julian Raymond, compilation producer; Jeff Pollack, music supervisor (Glen Campbell: I'll Be Me)beat 4 others- Jim Beanz and Timbaland, compilation producers; Jen Ross, music supervisor (Empire: Season 1)
- Mike Knobloch and Dana Sano, compilation producers (Fifty Shades of Grey)
- Julianne Jordan, Harvey Mason Jr. and Julia Michels, compilation producers (Pitch Perfect 2)
- Ava DuVernay, compilation producer; Morgan Rhodes, music supervisor (Selma)
| Not listed |
| 2015 | Kristen Anderson-Lopez, Robert Lopez, Tom MacDougall and Chris Montan, compilation producers; David Boucher, engineer/mixer (Frozen)beat 4 others- Susan Jacobs and David O. Russell, compilation producers (American Hustle)
- Peter Afterman and Harry Weinger, compilation producers; Budd Carr and Margaret Yen, music supervisors (Get On Up: The James Brown Story)
- James Gunn, compilation producer; Dave Jordan, music supervisor (Guardians of the Galaxy: Awesome Mix Vol. 1)
- Robbie Robertson, compilation producer; Randall Poster, music supervisor (The Wolf of Wall Street)
| Not listed |
| 2014 | Butch Vig, compilation producer; James Brown, engineer/mixer (Sound City: Real to Reel)beat 4 others- Quentin Tarantino, compilation producer (Django Unchained)
- Baz Luhrmann and Anthony Seyler, compilation producers (The Great Gatsby (Deluxe Edition))
- Cameron Mackintosh, Lee McCutcheon and Stephan Metcalfe, compilation producers (Les Misérables (Deluxe Edition))
- Stephan Badger and Greg Camalier, compilation producers (Muscle Shoals)
| Not listed |
| 2013 | Woody Allen, producer (Midnight in Paris)beat 4 others- Dondi Bastone and Alexander Payne, producers (The Descendants)
- Chris Blackwell and Barry Cole, producers (Marley)
- Kaylin Frank and Mitchell Leib, producers (The Muppets)
- Adam Anders and Peer Åström, producers (Rock of Ages)
| Not listed |
| 2012 | Stewart Lerman, Randall Poster and Kevin Weaver, producers; Stewart Lerman, engineer/mixer (Boardwalk Empire: Volume 1)beat 4 others- Christina Aguilera (Burlesque)
- Adam Anders, Peer Åström and Ryan Murphy, producers (Glee: The Music, Volume 4)
- Alan Menken, producer (Tangled)
- Gary Calamar, producer (True Blood – Volume 3)
| Not listed |
| 2011 | Stephen Bruton and T Bone Burnett, producers (Crazy Heart)beat 4 others- Adam Anders, Peer Åström and Ryan Murphy, producers (Glee: The Music, Volume 1)
- Blake Leyh and Tony Seyler, producers (Tremé)
- Alan Ball, Gary Calamar and Kevin Weaver, producers (True Blood – Volume 2)
- Paul Katz and Alexandra Patsavas, producers (The Twilight Saga: Eclipse)
| Not listed |
| 2010 | A. R. Rahman, producer; H. Sridhar, P. A. Deepak and Vivianne Chaix, engineers/mixers (Slumdog Millionaire)beat 4 others- Steve Jordan, producer (Cadillac Records)
- Quentin Tarantino, producer (Inglourious Basterds)
- Alan Ball, Gary Calamar and Kevin Weaver, producers (True Blood)
- Paul Katz and Alexandra Patsavas, producers (Twilight)
| Not listed |
| 2009 | Jason Reitman, Margaret Yen and Peter Afterman, producers (Juno)beat 4 others- Kathy Nelson and Ridley Scott, producers (American Gangster)
- Richard Lewis, producer (August Rush)
- Benny Anderson, producer (Mamma Mia!)
- Mike Higham, producer (Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street)
| Not listed |
| 2008 | George Martin and Giles Martin, producers; Paul Hicks, engineer/mixer (Love)beat 4 others- T Bone Burnett, Matthias Gohl and Elliot Goldenthal, producers (Across the Universe)
- Harvey Mason, Randy Spendlove, Matt Sullivan and Damon Thomas, producers (Dreamgirls)
- Marc Shaiman, producer (Hairspray)
- Glen Hansard, producer (Once)
| Not listed |
| 2007 | T Bone Burnett, producer; Mike Piersante, engineer/mixer (Walk the Line)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Gustavo Santaolalla, producer (Brokeback Mountain)
- Chris Montan and Randy Newman, producers (Cars)
- Mitchell Leib and Alexandra Patsavas, producers (Grey's Anatomy – Volume 2)
- Mychael Danna, producer (Little Miss Sunshine)
| Not listed |
| 2006 | James Austin, Stuart Benjamin and Taylor Hackford, compilation producers (Ray)beat 4 others- Phil Ramone, compilation producer (Beyond the Sea)
- Brian McNelis and Skip Williamson, compilation producers (Napoleon Dynamite)
- Steve Berkowitz, Bruce Dickinson and Jeff Rosen, compilation producers (No Direction Home: The Soundtrack – Bootleg Series, Vol. 7)
- Gary Calamar, Thomas Golubic and Errol Kolosine, compilation producers (Six Feet Under, Vol. 2: Everything Ends)
| Not listed |
| 2005 | Zach Braff, compilation producer (Garden State)beat 4 others- T Bone Burnett, compilation producer (Cold Mountain)
- Peter Asher and Stephen Endelman, compilation producers (De-Lovely)
- Quentin Tarantino, compilation producer (Kill Bill Vol. 2)
- Andrew Adamson, Christopher Douridas and Michael Ostin, compilation producers (Shrek 2)
| Not listed |
| 2004 | Randy Spendlove and Ric Wake, compilation producers; Dan Hetzel, engineer/mixer (Chicago)beat 4 others- Robbie Robertson, Martin Scorsese and Hal Willner, compilation producers (Gangs of New York)
- Quentin Tarantino, compilation producer (Kill Bill Vol. 1)
- CJ Vanston, compilation producer (A Mighty Wind)
- Jack Black, Richard Linklater and Randall Poster, compilation producers (School of Rock)
| Not listed |
| 2003 | Ted Greenberg, Allan Slutsky and Harry Weinger, compilation producers; Ted Greenberg and Kooster McAllister, engineers/mixers (Standing in the Shadows of Motown)beat 4 others- Debra MacCulloch, Howard Paar and Stacy Peralta, compilation producers (Dogtown and Z-Boys)
- Andy Gershon, Kate Hyman and Jon Sidel, compilation producers (I Am Sam)
- Gary Calamar and Thomas Golubić, compilation producers (Six Feet Under)
- Alfonso Cuarón, Camilo Lara and Liza Richardson, compilation producers (Y Tu Mamá También)
| Not listed |
| 2002 | T Bone Burnett, producer (O Brother, Where Art Thou?)beat 4 others- Nick Angel and Kathy Nelson, compilation producers (Bridget Jones's Diary)
- Marius De Vries, Baz Luhrmann and Anton Monsted, compilation producers (Moulin Rouge!)
- Marylata E. Jacob and Michael Ostin, compilation producers (Shrek)
- Martin Bruestle and David Chase, compilation producers (The Sopranos: Peppers & Eggs)
| Not listed |
| 2001 | Danny Bramson and Cameron Crowe, producers (Almost Famous)beat 4 others- Jay David Saks, producer (Fantasia 2000)
- John Cusack and Kathy Nelson, producers (High Fidelity)
- Aimee Mann (Magnolia)
- Martin Bruestle and David Chase, producers (The Sopranos)
| Not listed |
| 2000 | Phil Collins and Mark Mancina, producers (Tarzan)beat 4 others- Chris Douridas and Sam Mendes, producers (American Beauty)
- Danny Bramson and Guy Oseary, compilation producers (Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me)
- Jason Bentley, Guy Oseary and Russ Rieger, compilation producers (The Matrix)
- Hans Zimmer, producer (The Prince of Egypt)
| Not listed |