| 2025 | Simon Hilton & Sean Ono Lennon (Mind Games)beat 5 others- Nick Azinas & Mike Hicks (Half Living Things)
- Kate Bush & Albert McIntosh (Hounds of Love - The Boxes of Lost at Sea)
- Doug Cunningham & Jason Noto (In Utero)
- Takahiro Kurashima & Marek Polewski (Unsuk Chin)
- Rebeka Arce & Farbod Kokaki (We Blame Chicago)
| Not listed |
| 2024 | Jeri Heiden & John Heidon (For the Birds: The Birdsong Project)beat 4 others- Jeff Mangum, Daniel Murphy & Mark Ohe (The Collected Works of Neutral Milk Hotel)
- Duy Dao (Gieo)
- Bo Burnham & Daniel Calderwood (Inside (Deluxe Box Set))
- Masaki Koike (Words & Music, May 1965 (Deluxe Edition))
| Not listed |
| 2023 | Lisa Glines, Doran Tyson & Dave Van Patten (In and Out of the Garden: Madison Square Garden '81, '82, '83)beat 4 others- Josh Abrahams, Steve Berman, Jimmy Iovine, John Janick & Jason Sangerman (Artists Inspired by Music: Interscope Reimagined)
- Berit Gwendolyn Gilma (Big Mess)
- Jenny Krackenberger & Anna McCaleb (Black Pumas (Collector's Edition Box Set))
- Paul Sahre, John Flansburgh, Brian Karlsson & John Linnell (Book)
| Not listed |
| 2022 | Darren Evans, Dhani Harrison & Olivia Harrison (All Things Must Pass: 50th Anniversary Edition)beat 4 others- Lordess Foudre & Christopher Leckie (Color Theory)
- Simon Moore (The Future Bites (Limited Edition Box Set))
- Dan Calderwood & Jon King (77-81)
- Ramón Coronado & Marshall Rake (Swimming in Circles)
| Not listed |
| 2021 | Lawrence Azerrad & Jeff Tweedy (Ode to Joy)beat 4 others- Linn Wie Andersen, Simon Earith, Paul McCartney & James Musgrave (Flaming Pie (Collector's Edition))
- Lisa Glines & Doran Tyson (Giants Stadium 1987, 1989, 1991)
- Jeff Schulz (Mode)
- Michael Cina & Molly Smith (The Story of Ghostly International)
| Not listed |
| 2020 | Masaki Koike (Woodstock – Back to the Garden: The Definitive 50th Anniversary Archive)beat 4 others- Stanley Donwood & Tchocky (Anima)
- Amanda Chiu, Mark Farrow & David Gray (Gold in Brass Age)
- Josh Cheuse (1963: New Directions)
- Marek Polewski (The Radio Recordings 1939-1945)
| Not listed |
| 2019 | Meghan Foley, Annie Stoll & Al Yankovic (Squeeze Box: The Complete Works of "Weird Al" Yankovic)beat 4 others- Arian Buhler, Charles Dooher, Jeff Fura, Scott Sandler & Matt Taylor (Appetite For Destruction (Locked 'n Loaded Box))
- Carson Ellis, Jeri Heiden & Glen Nakasako (I'll Be Your Girl)
- Lisa Glines, Doran Tyson & Roy Henry Vickers (Pacific Northwest '73–'74: The Complete Recordings)
- Sarah Dodds & Shauna Dodds (Too Many Bad Habits)
| Not listed |
| 2018 | Lawrence Azerrad, Timothy Daly & David Pescovitz (The Voyager Golden Record: 40th Anniversary Edition)beat 4 others- Tim Breen (Bobo Yeye: Belle Epoque in Upper Volta)
- Tom Hingston (Lovely Creatures: The Best of Nick Cave and the Bad Seeds)
- Masaki Koike (May 1977: Get Shown the Light)
- Tim Breen, Benjamin Marra & Ken Shipley (Warfaring Strangers: Acid Nightmares)
| Not listed |
| 2017 | Gérard Lo Monaco (Edith Piaf 1915–2015)beat 4 others- Jonathan Dagan & Mathias Host Normark (401 Days)
- Samuel Burgess-Johnson & Matthew Healy (I Like It When You Sleep, for You Are So Beautiful yet So Unaware of It (Box Set))
- Matt Taylor (Paper Wheels (Deluxe Limited Edition))
- Simon Earith & James Musgrave (Tug of War (Deluxe Edition))
| Not listed |
| 2016 | Susan Archie, Dean Blackwood & Jack White (The Rise & Fall of Paramount Records, Volume Two (1928-32))repeatbeat 5 others- Leif Podhajsky (Beneath the Skin (Deluxe Box Set))
- Sasha Barr & Josh Tillman (I Love You, Honeybear (Limited Edition Deluxe Vinyl))
- Stephen Kennedy & James Tilley (Sticky Fingers (Super Deluxe Edition))
- Doran Tyson & Steve Vance (30 Trips Around the Sun)
- Carson Ellis, Jeri Heiden & Glen Nakasako (What a Terrible World, What a Beautiful World (Deluxe Box Set))
| Not listed |
| 2015 | Susan Archie, Dean Blackwood & Jack White (The Rise & Fall of Paramount Records, Volume One (1917-27))beat 4 others- Leland Meiners & Ken Shipley (Cities of Darkscorch)
- Gary Burden & Jenice Heo (A Letter Home (Vinyl Box Set))
- Andy Carne (Sparks (Deluxe Album Box Set))
- Jessica Dessner, Lisa Glines, Doran Tyson & Steve Vance (Spring 1990 (The Other One))
| Not listed |
| 2014 | Simon Earith and James Musgrave (Wings Over America (Deluxe Edition))beat 4 others- Charles Dooher & Scott Sandler (The Brussels Affair)
- Mayer Hawthorne (How Do You Do (Limited Edition Box Set))
- Ross Stirling (The Road to Red Rocks (Special Edition))
- Masaki Koike (The Smith Tapes)
| Not listed |
| 2013 | Fritz Klaetke (Woody at 100: The Woody Guthrie Centennial Collection)beat 4 others- Rob Sheridan (The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo (Soundtrack from the Motion Picture))
- Liz Kweller (Go Fly a Kite)
- Simon Earith & James Musgrave (Ram)
- Stephen Kennedy (Some Girls: Super Deluxe Edition)
| Not listed |
| 2012 | Dave Bett & Michelle Holme (The Promise: The Darkness on the Edge of Town Story)beat 4 others- Donald Twain & Zachariah Wildwood (The King of Limbs)
- Matt Taylor & Ellen Wakayama (25th Anniversary Music Box)
- James Spindler (25 Years)
- David Gorman (Wingless Angels – Deluxe Edition)
| Not listed |
| 2011 | Rob Jones & Jack White (Under Great White Northern Lights (Limited Edition Box Set))beat 4 others- Tom Lunt, Rob Sevier & Ken Shipley (Light: On the South Side)
- Jeff Anderson & Vaughan Oliver (Minotaur (Deluxe Edition))
- Daniel Reiss & Klaus Voormann (A Sideman's Journey (Limited Collector's Super Deluxe Box Set))
- Qing-Yang Xiao (Story Island)
| Not listed |
| 2010 | Gary Burden, Jenice Heo and Neil Young (The Archives Vol. 1 1963–1972)beat 4 others- Mathieu Bitton and Scott Webber (A Cabinet of Curiosities)
- Masaki Koike (The Clifford Ball)
- Stefan Sagmeister (Everything That Happens Will Happen Today)
- Jordan Butcher (Lost in the Sound of Separation (Deluxe Edition))
| Not listed |
| 2009 | Stanley Donwood, Mel Maxwell and Xiaan Munro (In Rainbows)beat 4 others- Trent Reznor & Rob Sheridan (Ghosts I–IV)
- Qing-Yang Xiao (Poems & Songs)
- Alex Kirzhner & Panic! at the Disco (Pretty. Odd.)
- Aimee Mann & Gail Marowitz (@#%&*! Smilers)
| XL/ATO |
| 2008 | Masaki Koike (What It Is! Funky Soul and Rare Grooves (1967–1977))beat 4 others- Matt Taylor, Ellen Wakayama & Gerard Way (The Black Parade – Special Edition)
- Alex Kirzhner (A Fever You Can't Sweat Out – Limited Edition Collectible Deluxe Box)
- Stan Chow (Icky Thump – Limited Edition USB Flash Drive)
- Matt Taylor & Valo (Venus Doom)
| Not listed |
| 2007 | Flea, John Frusciante, Anthony Kiedis, Chad Smith & Matt Taylor (Stadium Arcadium)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Howard Fritzson, Dan Ichimoto & Seth Rothstein (The Cellar Door Sessions 1970)
- Susan Archie & Henry Owings (Fonotone Records)
- Hugh Brown & Jean Krikorian (A Life Less Lived – The Gothic Box)
- Hugh Brown, Sheryl Farber & Maria Villar (One Kiss Can Lead to Another: Girl Group Sounds Lost & Found)
|  Warner Bros. |
| 2006 | Ian Cuttler (The Legend)beat 4 others- Susan Archie & Noel Waggener (Holy Ghost: Rare & Unissued Recordings (1962–70))
- Hugh Brown & Jeff Lyons (Pure Genius: The Complete Atlantic Recordings)
- Hugh Brown & Sheryl Farber (Weird Tales of the Ramones)
- Howard Fritzson & Michelle Holme (You Ain't Talkin' to Me – Charlie Poole and the Roots of Country Music)
| Not listed |
| 2005 | Stefan Sagmeister (Once in a Lifetime)beat 4 others- Stefan Sagmeister (The Complete Verve Master Takes)
- Susan Archie (Goodbye, Babylon)
- Michele Horie & Ryan Rogers (The Hip Hop Box)
- Christine Cano (Unearthed)
| Not listed |
| 2004 | Julian Alexander, Howard Fritzson & Seth Rothstein (The Complete Jack Johnson Sessions)beat 4 others- Michael Amzalag, Mathias Augustinyak & Gabríela Friðriksdóttir (Family Tree)
- Kathleen Philpott & Mark Tappin (Furious Angels)
- Dave Bett & Sheri Lee (Scarlet's Walk)
- Doug Cunningham & Jason Noto (Sing the Sorrow)
| Not listed |
| 2003 | Susan Archie (Screamin' and Hollerin' the Blues: The Worlds of Charley Patton)beat 4 others- Sevie Bates (Can You Dig It? The '70s Soul Experience)
- Mary Fagot, Joshua Liberson, George Mimnaugh & Ethan Trask (Capitol Records Sixtieth Anniversary 1942–2002)
- Hugh Brown & Julie Vlasak (Like Omigod! The 80s Pop Culture Box (Totally))
- Dave Bett & Sheri Lee (Ultra-Lounge – Vegas Baby!)
| Revenant |
| 2002 | Hugh Brown & Steve Vance (Brain in a Box – The Science Fiction Collection)beat 4 others- Christian Calabro (Charlie Parker: The Complete Savoy and Dial Studio Recordings 1944–1948)
- Dave Bett & Sheri Lee (El Cancionero: Mas y Mas – A History of the Band from East L.A.)
- Ron Jaramillo & Adam Owett (Lady Day: The Complete Billie Holiday on Columbia 1933–1944)
- Carol Bobolts, Jaime Boyle & Deb Schuler (The Long Road to Freedom – An Anthology of Black Music)
| Not listed |
| 2001 | Arnold Levine & Frank Harkins (The Complete Columbia Recordings 1955–1961)beat 4 others- Ian Cuttler (The Complete Hot Five and Hot Seven Recordings)
- Hollis King (The Complete Lester Young Studio Sessions on Verve)
- Jared Eberhardt, Michael Jager & Todd Wender (Hampton Comes Alive)
- Rachel Gutek (Respect: A Century of Women in Music)
| Not listed |
| 2000 | Ron Jaramillo & Arnold Levine (Miles Davis – The Complete Bitches Brew Sessions)beat 4 others- Gordon H. Jee (The Blue Note Years – 60th Anniversary Box Set)
- Giulio Turturro (The Complete Jazz at the Philharmonic on Verve 1944–1949)
- James Austin, Hugh Brown & Julie Vlasak (Hot Rods & Custom Classics – Cruisin' Songs & Highway Hits)
- Hollis King (John Coltrane – The Classic Quartet: The Complete Impulse! Recordings)
| Not listed |
| 1999 | Jim Kemp and Virginia Team (The Complete Hank Williams)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Mark Michaelson (The Best of William Burroughs from Giorno Poetry Systems)
- Chika Azuma (Ella and Duke at the Cote D'Azur)
- Janet Boye & Arnold Levine (The Complete Studio Recordings of The Miles Davis Quintet 1965–1968)
- Andy Engel & Johnny Lee (Miss Peggy Lee)
| Not listed |
| 1998 | David Gorman, Hugh Brown & Rachel Gutek (Beg Scream and Shout! The Big Ol' Box of '60s Soul)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Patricia Lie (The Complete Bill Evans on Verve)
- Giulio Turturro (The Complete Ella Fitzgerald & Louis Armstrong on Verve)
- Carol Bobolts, Laurie Goldman & Jack O'Neil (Cuba: I Am Time)
- Bryan Lasley (Shakedown! The Texas Tapes Revisited)
| Not listed |
| 1997 | Arnold Levine and Chika Azuma (The Complete Columbia Studio Recordings)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Michael Lang, David Lau & Giulio Turturro (Blues, Boogie, & Bop: The 1940s Mercury Sessions)
- JoDee Stringham (The Complete Reprise Studio Recordings)
- Giulio Turturro (The Man from Ipanema)
- Chris Bilheimer & Michael Stipe (New Adventures in Hi-Fi)
| Not listed |
| 1996 | Frank Zappa & Gail Zappa (Civilization Phaze III)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Mark Farrow (Alternative)
- Allen Weinberg (Box of Fire)
- Storm Thorgerson (Pulse)
- Blind Melon, Jeffery Fey, Chris Jones & Tommy Steele (Soup)
| Not listed |
| 1995 | Chris Thompson (The Complete Ella Fitzgerald Songbooks)unverifiedbeat 4 others- Beborah Norcross (Boingo)
- David Lau (The Complete Bud Powell on Verve)
- Chris Bilheimer, Tom Recchion & Michael Stipe (Monster)
- Geoff Gans & Coco Shinomiya (Songs of the West)
| Not listed |
